From Policy to Practice: The Restitution of Books in European Libraries and Heritage Institutions
Organized by: CERL (Consortium of European Research Libraries) in collaboration with the French ministry of Culture
Speaker(s): Agnieszka Franczyk‐Cegła,Elżbieta Przyłuska,Kristian Jensen,Louise Malécot,Marian Lefferts,Marianna Morreale,Nikolaus Weichselbaumer,Pierre-Jean Riamond,Stefania Siano
https://www.cerl.org/wp-admin/media-upload.php?post_id=23565&type=image&TB_iframe=1
In conjunction with government and European representatives, invited by the organisers, we aim to focus on the legal framework for the restitution of books in Europe, and on how legal definitions as well as public, societal and political contexts have had an impact – and will in the future have an impact – on library management and actual practice in libraries.

We wish to create an atmosphere where participants can share experiences of complex, perhaps even controversial issues, which may still be unresolved or which may be associated with strongly held positions in the public debate. In order to achieve this we are planning a closed workshop for high level professionals from CERL member institutions only.
We therefore ask that Senior Management of the CERL member library nominates a member of staff (one member of staff per CERL member, in the first instance). Please send your nomination, outlining why the topic of the workshop is particularly relevant to this member of staff, to secretariat@cerl.org.
While this is a CERL members-only event, we draw your attention to a public conference on Provenance and Restitution which CERL and the IFLA Rare Books and Special Collections Standing Committee will co-organise in August 2027 as a Satellite Meeting to the IFLA’s annual WILC (London, August 2027).
Programme
9.00 Registration and Welcome
9.30 – 10.00 Setting the stage
– Pierre Jean Riamond, Chef du bureau du patrimoine
Service du livre et de la lecture, Direction générale des médias et des industries culturelles, Ministère de la culture, France
– Louise Malécot (video or online), Project Officer CEM/CLT, UNESCO
10.00 – 10.15 BREAK
10.15 – 10.45
– Stefania Siano, Archaeologist officer, Coordinator for activities related to the Council of the European Union, Multilateral Platforms, European Data Group, Recovery and Restitution of Cultural Property, and the 1970 UNESCO Convention, Department for General Administration, Directorate General for European and International Affairs, Service I – European and International Affairs, Italy
– Elżbieta Przyłuska, Senior Specialist for the Restitution of Polish Wartime Losses Abroad, Office for the Restitution of Cultural Property, Department of Cultural Heritage, Ministry of Culture, Poland
10.45 – 11.00 CERL Participants introduce themselves
11.00 – 12.00 Engaging with external parties (introduction by Kristian Jensen)
Covering themes such as:
- Government/police/lawyers
- Restitution to whom? : is there a direct heir, or a direct successor, or is it more ethical consideration in your institution (e.g. Nazi looted material, and where we need to establish to whom we should restitute). Institutional expectations from claimants (proof?)
- And related to this: is the process a form of Action or Reaction: organisational aspects of projects and actors impact on acquisitions
- Public engagement: who do we engage with, how do we find the right partners for a dialogue, how do we balance confidentiality and transparency, how do we mediate tensions between legal requirements and public expectations
12.00 – 12.30 Report back from each of the groups (Moderator – Marian Lefferts)
12.30 – 13.30 LUNCH
13.30 – 14:30 Organising the work (introduction by Kristian Jensen)
Covering themes such as:
- How do you organise the work in your library? A single point of responsibility for all restitution issues? A standing committee or ad hoc teams and projects? Ensuring continuity of practice and quality of work across disparate cases?
- Do you need to hire in specialists? How does that work with confidentiality?
- Do you have different procedures for items with different historical back grounds (colonial ear acquisitions, Nazi spoliation, illegal import, plain theft…)
- Are your procedures and policies public? Why? Why not?
14:30 – 15:00 Report back from each of the groups (Moderator – Marian Lefferts)
15:00 – 15:30 TEA
15.30 – 16.30 Plenary session and conclusions
- The restitution of books comes with specific issues. Are they adequately reflected in national and international legislation and guidance?
- How can we better ensure that they are considered?
EVENT INFORMATION
Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin
